NEWS

Oil bunkering: Ukrainians discharged and acquitted

A Federal High Court sitting in Port Harcourt has discharged and acquitted four Ukrainians  and a vessel charged  for  illegal oil bunkering by the Federal Government of Nigeria. The four Ukrainian Vaskov Andriy, Garchev Mykhaylo, Shula Madyslay, Orlovkyi Lyvan and a chartered Vessel MT. San Pedro PIO, were arrested by the Nigerian Navy in September 2018.

They were arraigned and tried before the court on Initial two count charge of conspiracy to deal in petroleum products and dealing in petroleum products without permit, the charge was later amended and increased to six counts.  But they pleaded not guilty to the charges.

The presiding Judge, Justice Adamu Turaki Mohammed, discharged and acquitted  the four after finding them not guilty on all the six counts.  The Ukrainian and their ship were arraigned before the court on march 21,2019.  In his verdict, the Judge  declared that there was no evidence that they broke the law. Consequently,  he ordered that their vessel, which was seized, released forthwith.

 The offences of conspiracy to deal in petroleum products, dealing in petroleum products, making false documents and uttering documents alleged to have been committed by the defendants are contrary to sections 3(6) and 1(17)(a), 1 (2)(c) of the Miscellaneous Offences Act, 2007.  During the trial, the team of the prosecuting counsels led by Samuel Chime called nine witnesses and tendered  ten exhibits.

However, the defendants denied the allegations, and in their defence, their counsel Barrister Babajide Koku SAN, leading six other senior counsels called five witnesses and tendered three exhibits 

Koku contended that the allegation  was baseless because the defendants obtained appropriate authorisation for their  operations. In his verdict Justice Adamu  Turaki Mohammed upheld Koku’s submission  and said the prosecution failed to prove its case. The judge declare that “ by virtue of the sale agreement between AUGUST A Energy and ANOSYKE Group of Companies, the amended purchase order together with evidence of Prosecution witness 6 under cross-examination, who admitted that the Department of Petroleum Resources (DPR) import permit is valid, I have no doubt that the Prosecution has failed to prove that the defendants had no licence or authority to deal in Petroleum Product. I so hold.

“Again, Exhibit A1 -Navy verification certificate has shown that Naval approval was obtained in respect of Exhibit J-,product (cargo) on board while the Department of Petroleum Resources import permit attached to Exhibit 63 has shown that the necessary permit was equally secured in respect of Exhibit J from the DPR. “It is clear both from Exhibit A1- Navy verification certificate and the DPR permit, that the company in whose favour the approvals were granted is ANOSYKE Group of Companies.

“Similarly, as I have held above that the Prosecution has failed to prove Count 2 of the charge against the Defendants, I am equally unable to infer, from the entire evidence adduced by the prosecution, how the Defendants conspired with each other to, without lawful authority or appropriate licence import; distribute or deal in/with Petroleum Product as contained in Count 1, particularly having regard to Exhibit A1 and the DPR permit attached to   exhibit G3 -the letter of their solicitor . I so hold

  Accordingly, therefore,the  defendants are found not guilty as charged and are hereby discharged and acquitted.  As a consequence, the order made on the 26th September, 2018 in respect of Exhibit J- the product cargo on board is hereby vacated. 

Share This
Openlife Reporter

Recent Posts

Zenith Bank’s 20th Christmas Light-Up Turns Ajose Adeogun Street Into A Must Visit Spot For 2026 Yuletide

Zenith Bank Plc has transformed Ajose Adeogun Street, Victoria Island, Lagos into a breathtaking spectacle…

6 hours ago

APC Has Lost The Argument, The People, 2027,  Now Resorts To Thuggery But NDC Remains Focused On New Nigeria—Osa Director

APC Has Lost The Argument   OpenLife News reports that the Nigeria Democratic Congress, NDC,…

10 hours ago

Exactly 2 Months To 2027 Election, Atiku’s Fate On The Ballot Hangs In The Balance — Is His 7th Presidential Dream Over?

Exactly 2 months to the January 16, 2027 presidential election, Atiku Abubakar's fate on the…

17 hours ago

Asari Dokubo Spent 3 Days In Edo After Death Threats — And Left With Gunshots On The Water. Where Was The Government?

After weeks of death threats and a reported bounty on his head, Asari Dokubo entered…

20 hours ago

Polaris Bank’s Charity Trust Support For 640 Students Reflects Our Commitment To Meaningful Social Impact On Education — Kayode Lawal

Polaris Bank, in partnership with Evolve Charity Trust, has provided learning materials to 640 students…

22 hours ago

SunTrust Bank In Deep Crisis, Rocked By Top-Level Resignations Amid EFCC Investigation

SunTrust Bank In Deep Crisis, Rocked By Top-Level Resignations Amid EFCC Investigation

1 day ago

This website uses cookies.